网页
综合
更新时间 2025-12-18 17:05:44
Discussion of We're Building AI to Replace Ourselves. What's the Plan? - DEV Community
自动蜘蛛
dev.to
正文约 6000 字
Sylwia Laskowska on November 04, 2026
Displaying a subset of the total comments. Please sign in to view all comments on this post.
My view is that the AI bubble hasn't burst yet. Using AI is still relatively cheap, and I suspect a lot of the real cost is being subsidized. Once we have to pay the full price, we'll see how much we actually use it every day.
But AI has already changed how we work, and I do think we'll need fewer people in our industry. What worries me is what happens when the bubble bursts and a lot of startups built around cheap AI APIs start crashing. But that's just my prediction.
There are three things I'm more confident about.
First, even the best agents, like Fable, Argon, and Astra, deliver impressive results, but I doubt they're affordable enough to replace developers at scale. So we end up using cheaper, less capable agents that still need human supervision.
Second, I get mad at AI agents almost every day. 🤣 They make wrong assumptions, add unnecessary code, or turn simple features into something much more complex than necessary. Someone still has to review and fix all of that.
Third, security. Even my small experiments have shown how easily AI agents can be tricked, and sometimes it doesn't take much effort at all. (And I already have another article ready about tricking AI agents through WebMCP. 😁)
So yes, I think OpenAI and Anthropic are overselling the idea of AI replacing developers. The compute needed to do that reliably at scale would be extremely expensive, and you'd still need experienced people to supervise those agents.
But I wouldn't complain about a three-day workweek! Although, considering Altman's recent comments about RAM, I'm starting to wonder if the plan is to replace developers or just take all the RAM from our PCs first. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hahahaha, I literally ask my friends every day if they've already sent their RAM to Altman! 🤣🤣
But yes, I agree! The bubble might burst, agents still need supervision, and I imagine people working in cybersecurity are having the time of their lives right now. There's no way we're handing all of that over to machines anytime soon. And the amount of dependencies LLM-generated code can introduce... well... 😅
Who knows what the future will bring, though? Assuming Altman doesn't steal everyone's RAM first, I think we'll see more and more people moving toward local models, and that's going to be really interesting too!
And by the way, now I'm officially offended that you don't want to travel to conferences with me! Another fantastic talk about WebMCP vulnerabilities is going to waste! Think about it! KubeCon is already a lost opportunity, but imagine how perfect this would be for AGNTCon in London next September! Pure gold!
C'mon, Sylwia, don't be mad at me. Now I feel guilty. 😢
I told you I couldn't make it to KubeCon, mainly because I didn't have enough time and had family responsibilities, but also because I have literally zero experience speaking at conferences and I'm not confident enough yet. And now AGNTCon in London? You're really not going to let me hide behind my keyboard, are you? 🤣
But seriously, I appreciate your confidence in my experiments. Maybe one day you'll convince me to actually get on stage. Let's just hope Skynet doesn't take over before then. 😅
Hahahaha, well, if you change your mind, just let me know! London isn't until September, so there's still plenty of time!
Would love to see some numbers around you getting mad with agents every day. Are they actually slowing you down? Its been known for a long time that rework is the speed-killer, so if your agents are making you re-work their output, maybe you should compare that with doing the work yourself. Would love to see the data.
"AI will even be sitting in your toilet, ..."
Not on my toilets, for sure 🤣
Joke apart, I don't think AI is going to replace us. You've touched the aspect of economy already. If everyone is unemployed, no one pays, so it won't happen.
How are we going to solve the energy requirement needed for all those GPUs? Actually replacing human brains from work needs 1000x more energy than what we produce now. Actual hardware required to produce energy (whether it's solar panels or turbines) requires a lots and lots of work, and time consuming too. There's no indication that we are even close to solving that.
Serious software like OS, Banking, Medical etc. will always require human engineers. Even if AI can do that perfectly, we'll mandate humans in those positions. For our security from AI take over. We'll do it. Rest assured. Our governments may be run by idiots, but they surely don't act like idiots when their power is threatened. So, that won't happen.
Software Engineers will become AI + Software engineers. Normal humans will do cute stuff like small games, web pages, personal tools etc. Any software that require long term maintenance, will need humans. Again, if nothing else, then for our own safety. Besides, 99% of world population don't have tech savvy brains to maintain software that needs long term support. Because of AI, they'll become even less tech savvy. Even for simple decision making, we'll need software engineers.
Our work will become more, not less. Previously it was just software, now it's software + AI. And because AI is making it easier, we'll get paid less unless we are very good at both AI and software engineering. The ones in the bottom 99% will work more because they'll get paid less. The ones in the top 1% will work more to remain in the top 1%.
Software security will be a nightmare. Previously it was against human hackers, in future it'll be human hackers combined with AI, and millions of Rogue AI agents combining against humans and other AI agents. So, normal people will never be able to battle that. If anything, we'll need more IT people.
My Prediction: every job can be replaced because of AI with the only exception of really good Software Engineers (who are also AI engineers). Computer Science will go down for a w
本页为82搜索生成的网页快照,内容来自站内索引;演示数据的原文链接仅作示例。